Connect with us

News

Judging Controversy: Ashlee Evans-Smith vs. Marion Reneau

Matthew Wells

Published

on

The UFC Fight Pass prelims of UFC Fight Night 83 featured a bantamweight matchup between Ashlee Evans-Smith and #11 Marion Reneau. The fight itself proved to be close as it progressed, but the lasting memory most will take away from this will be the judges scorecard.

Marion Reneau opened the fight in impressive fashion by hitting Evans-Smith with crisp striking while utilizing effective movement and footwork. Reneau came close to finishing the fight by unleashing a flurry of punches while charging forward across the cage, which caused Evans-Smith to drop to one knee briefly:

To close out the round, Reneau caught a kick from Evans-Smith that would lead to a trip takedown, which then lead to a deep guillotine attempt that was broken up by the sound of the horn at the end of the first round. For those scoring the fight on social media, it was a round unanimously scored for Reneau.

The second round was closely contested and could have gone to either fighter. Evans-Smith looked a lot better than she did in the opening frame finding a home for some combinations, although many felt Reneau controlled the action. The significant occurrence in the final frame was a takedown from Evans-Smith in what was otherwise another close round, causing the fight to be decided by the judges’ scorecard.

What a scorecard it was.

CbxyIRaVIAAVk

The judges’ official scorecard would read a split decision in favor of Evans-Smith with scores of:

  • 30-27 in favor of Evans-Smith
  • 29-27 in favor of Evans-Smith
  • 29-28 in favor of Reneau

Two of the judges scored the first round of the fight for Evans-Smith, the round in which she was nearly knocked out and almost submitted.

The question that must be asked is were the judges confused by the names and/or very similar Reebok fight kits? Both fighters’ kits were very similar as well as their braided hairstyle.

The score of 29-27 is initially puzzling, considering no judge handed out a score of 8 for either fighter. Upon closer inspection, you’ll notice an error in math by the third judge, who scored the rounds 10, 9, and 9 respectively for Reneau, which if the simple addition were accurate, would result in a score of 28. Without the error, the final score should read 30-27, 29-28, 28-29 in favor of Evans-Smith by way of Split Decision.

The scorecard caused a firestorm across social media:

https://twitter.com/MMAdamMartin/status/701561731374587910

What are your thoughts on the scores of this fight? Sound off @MMALatestnws!


For the latest mma news, live event coverage, and more, follow @MMALatestnws on Twitter

 

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Interviews

UFC 219’s Jimmie Rivera to TJ Dillashaw “Defend Your Belt or Vacate.”

Harry Davies

Published

on

MMA Latest had the chance to talk to #4 ranked UFC bantamweight Jimmie “El Terror” Rivera ahead of his fight at UFC 219 against John Lineker.

Rivera (21-1) extended his unbeaten run to twenty when he defeated Thomas Almeida at UFC Long Island in July. Originally scheduled to face former bantamweight champion Dominick Cruz, we began by asking Rivera how the opponent change had affected his preparation for UFC 219.

The only thing that’s changed is the game plan, everything else stays the same. Cruz is more of an irritating fight because he just doesn’t stop moving, but with Lineker, he’s going to stay in the pocket and bang, and I love that.

Recently, Rivera posted a video to his Twitter account of him sparring with the recently crowned bantamweight champion, TJ Dillashaw. He told us about the context of this video, and how the sparring went down between them.

It was 3 or 4 years back. I think TJ had just lost to (John) Dodson on TUF. My teammate Louis Gaudinot was actually fighting Tim Elliott at the time, and we were in Milwaukee so I got to train with (Urijah) Faber and Dillashaw.

I just sent it to TJ to say, don’t forget what happened. I was getting the best of him, and I don’t really brag about it. But he wants to leave the weight class and fight DJ for the money fight, and I want to fight for the belt, so it’s defend your belt or vacate.

After briefly referencing the potential superfight between Demetrious Johnson and TJ Dillashaw, I asked Rivera about his thoughts on the somewhat flawed UFC rankings system, and title fights being put together purely for entertainment value.

It sucks. When I become champ I won’t be like a TJ or McGregor, I’m going to be like Demetrious Johnson and defend my belt against people coming up, it’s the right thing to do. If you want to win the belt and leave the division straight away, it’s kind of bullshit.

Rivera concluded by telling me that although he isn’t looking past Lineker at 219, “the only fight that makes sense after this one, is fighting TJ for the belt.”

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading

Announcement

Mark Hunt Returns to Fight Curtis Blaydes at UFC 221

Published

on

UFC 221 in Perth has officially added a another Australian to the main card. Joining Robert Whittaker is the knockout legend Mark Hunt.

The Daily Telegraph first reported that Hunt will be stepping into the octagon to face #9 Curtis Blaydes. Some weren’t sure if we would ever see Hunt fight again after he was pulled from the main event in UFC Fight Night 21 against Marcin Tybura. The UFC removed him due to “medical concerns” while Hunt was stating he was perfectly fine.

After getting evaluated and cleared to fight by Australian and American doctors, it looks like his time has come to return.  Hunt’s last fight was back in June when he derailed the Derrick Lewis hype train with a 4th round TKO win.

Hunt had been adamant about calling out #3 ranked heavyweight Fabricio Werdum and trying to get that rematch booked, labelling Werdum a “chicken shit” and a “coward.”

Curtis “Razor” Blaydes who has an 8-1 record, is coming off a TKO victory due to doctor stoppage at UFC 217 in November. Since losing to now title challenger Francis Ngannou in April of 2016, Blaydes has rattled off three straight wins over Alexey Oleynik, Daniel Omielanczuk, and Cody East.

With all this momentum from the win streak, Blaydes looks to capitalize and win the biggest fight of his career against Hunt.

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading

News

Valentina Shevchenko vs. Priscila Cachoeira Officially Booked for Belem, Brazil card

Published

on

The wait is over. Valentina Shevchenko (14-3, 3-2 UFC) will make her highly anticipated flyweight debut when the UFC returns to Brazil. She will face Priscila Cachoeira (8-0) on the February 3rd card scheduled for Belem, Brazil. Luciana Andrade was the first to report the match-up last week. On Tuesday, the UFC posted an article which stated the bout had been set.

Now that the flyweight tournament is over and the inaugural champion has her crown, many women shall migrate from the strawweight and bantamweight ranks in search of a more suitable weight class. The division is so infantile means a lot moving parts in the rankings. Yet, only women who fought at one hundred and twenty-five lbs. are ranked. Such practices muddy the title picture for the time being. Essentially ruling out the idea of Montano vs. Shevchenko for the first defense of the belt, illogical. An idea that floated around the internet until today’s confirmation of the newest female flyweight match-up. The TUF 26 winner, Nicco Montano called it, “kinda silly”, earlier this week while on The MMA Hour. Montano believes her first title defense, as it stands, should pit her against the original finalist of the flyweight tournament, Sijara Eubanks. Although Eubanks withdrew from the title fight, she is still ranked as the #1 contender in the division.

Shevchenko explained her desire for the flyweight belt on The MMA Hour, a week earlier than Montano, “For me it’s number one, to fight for the title… It doesn’t matter for me, if I have to have one fight before it, okay I will do it… my main goal is to be the champion… It doesn’t matter I move from one thirty-five to one twenty-five. My goal is still the same, to be the champion”. The Russian fighter is coming off an unsuccessful title shot in the bantamweight division against the current reigning champ, Amanda Nunes. The bout went to a decision after close five rounds, Nunes ultimately defeated Shevchenko via split decision (47-48, 48-47, 48-47).

Her opponent, Priscila Cachoeira, is not only new to the UFCs female flyweight division but the promotion’s roster as well. Cachoeira originally was scheduled to make her promotional debut against veteran Lauren Murphy at The Ultimate Fighter Finale 26. The Brazilian fighter withdrew from the bout due to visa issues. As a professional, she is undefeated with four knockouts in her eight fights.

UFC Belem is scheduled for February 3rd, 2018. The card will feature Timothy Johnson vs. Marcelo Golm in the heavyweight division. It will also have Thiago Santos taking on Anthony Smith in the middleweight division.

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading

Trending