Connect with us

Fighter Profile

Moving Brackets: The Good, Bad and Ugly of Changing Weight Divisions

Published

on

What factors come into play when a fighter loses? Sometimes it’s injuries, sometimes it’s mental and sometimes the man or woman just wasn’t good enough. But one major element that can completely sway an entire career is weight class. For some fighters moving weight class is an act of desperation, and sometimes it is the missing piece of the puzzle. Here is a look at some of the most famous weight class changes, for better and for worse.

Good

Chael Sonnen – 11-5-1 LHW, 18-9 MW

Joe Rogan himself said Chael Sonnen was the best talker in combat sports history, and you’d be hard-pressed to find someone better than ‘The American Gangster’, but it wasn’t until his move to middleweight in the UFC that the true and brash Chael P. came into our consciousness.

Despite an admirable record at 205lbs, Sonnen shined at the lower 185lb weight class where he was able to utilize his size and strength advantage much better. When comparing his Light Heavyweight performances against Jon Jones, Rashad Evans and Forrest Griffin against his Middleweight dominance against Brian Stann, Yushin Okami and Anderson Silva (up until he got submitted) it is apparently obvious that he was able to implement his wrestling-based game plan much better at 185lbs.

At 185lbs Sonnen was much stronger than his opponents, which usually made up for the skill differences between him and the best in the division. This strength advantage brought him all the way to two middleweight title shots.

Upon returning to Light Heavyweight in 2013 we saw exactly what happened when Chael came across the bigger and better men at 205lbs; he fell in two of his three fights that year.

Chael may have retired on a loss at Light Heavyweight, but every MMA fan knows that he never belonged in the cage with the top dogs at that weight class, and, that in his prime at 185 pounds, Chael Sonnen was a wrestling force not to be messed with.

Anthony Johnson- 1-0 HW, 7-0 LHW, 9-2 WW, 2-2 Catchweight

From missing weight by 12lbs and being cut by the UFC to now fighting for the light heavyweight title, Anthony Johnson has certainly been through the MMA ringer; and he owes his new lease on UFC life to his change of weight class.

From the first moment we saw Anthony Johnson in the UFC there were calls for him to move up in weight class. Walking around at well over 200lbs and cutting down to 170 was never a feat Johnson could sustain, and the toll it took on his body showed early in his career. Yes, Johnson had some sensational performances at welterweight such as his KO’s of Tommy Speer and Kevin Burns, but he was never an elite fighter at 170lbs. His loss against Josh Koscheck pretty much solidified Johnson’s welterweight career as a gatekeeper. To the relief of his many fans, Rumble took the final fight of his first UFC run against Vitor Belfort at middleweight, thinking that the extra 15lbs would provide what he needed to see the resurrection of his earlier form. After missing weight for the fight by a record 12lbs and, frankly, putting on a terrible performance, Johnson was cut by the UFC. Some thought Anthony was done with the premier MMA organization, but they would be mistaken. Rumble moved training camps to the Blackzilians and made the best decision of his whole career; to take his weight seriously.

After being cut from the UFC, Johnson missed weight yet again in his first post-UFC fight at Middleweight. Johnson then made his move from Middleweight’s 185lbs limit to Light Heavyweight’s 205lbs cap. It was yet another attempt to try and kick start his fighting career one last time. This would become the saving grace for Johnson as he is now undefeated since January 2012 as a Light Heavyweight, and is on a nine fight win streak.

From starting as a middle of the road competitor at Welterweight, Johnson is now one of the best in the 205lbs division, beating some of the best fighters on the planet along the way. At Light Heavyweight, Johnson has knocked out Alexander Gustafsson and Rodrigo Nogueira and dominated Phil Davis.

Now that Johnson doesn’t have to spend half his training camp cutting weight through harsh dieting and water loss, his cardio, strength and KO power is better than ever. Rumble arguably boasts the best one punch power in the UFC and some of the best takedown defense in his division, making him a true nightmare for any light heavyweight on the planet.

Robbie Lawler –11-5-1 MW, 14-3 WW, 0-2 Catchweight

The truest Cinderella story MMA has ever seen. From Strikeforce gatekeeper to UFC champion, Robbie Lawler’s 10 year journey to the UFC title all came to fruition when he moved down a weight class.

What’s unique about Robbie Lawler is that he started his career at his proper weight class of welterweight where he became a promising prospect in the early 2000’s. This all unravelled at UFC 47 when Lawler was KO’d by Nick Diaz in highlight-reel fashion, prompting his move up to middleweight in 2004.

From 2004 to 2013 Lawler competed as an undersized middleweight, having some success with some great KO’s, but always coming up short when he faced a higher level of oppositon. At middleweight, Lawler would simply get out muscled and out grappled by bigger and more technical fighters, suffering submission loses to strong grapplers in Ronaldo Souza, Jake Shields and Mayhem Miller during his tenure at 185lbs.

It would seem Robbie Lawler was destined to be just another good fighter, until his contract with Strikeforce was bought out by the UFC. Now a UFC fighter once again, Robbie realized that it was now or never for him, and decided to move back down to welterweight for his return to the UFC, nine years after his last fight in the promotion.

Lawler’s move back down to welterweight would give him back the size advantage he so sorely missed at middleweight and that, mixed with his insane KO power and aggressiveness, brought him all the way to the UFC welterweight title. What is next on the agenda for Robbie may be the biggest test of his career in the young phenom, Rory MacDonald. Despite his opponent’s impressive resume, Lawler has never been better than he is right now and regardless of how the bout goes, we all know Ruthless Robbie Lawler won’t go down without a fight.

Bad

Nate Diaz –1-2 WW, 15-7 LW, 1-1 Catchweight

Nate Diaz may be a fan favourite who has formerly fought his way to a lightweight title shot, but it was his ill-advised move to welterweight that got him a spot on this list.

At the start of his UFC career, Nate Diaz had won TUF 5 and was a legitimate lightweight contender, beating out many of the best in the division. But Diaz was never a top guy; falling to the likes of Clay Guida and Gray Maynard, a shot at the title was kept out of his grasp.

Frustrated with is ranking at Lightweight, Nate decided to move up to 170lbs where he would be bulkier and stronger, making it easier to fend off the wrestlers that had often beaten him at Lightweight. Unfortunately for Diaz, he just didn’t have the body for welterweight and was again falling to much bigger 170lbs fighters like Dong Hyun Kim and Rory Macdonald, who rag-dolled Diaz for 3 rounds.

Despite going back down to 155lbs In 2012 and earning a title shot, when Diaz came up against champion Benson Henderson, history repeated itself as the massive Henderson out grappled him for the entirety of their contest.

At 155lbs Nate Diaz was once a great fighter, but his problem has always been his size. Whether he was matched against bigger lightweights or tried his luck with a move to welterweight, Nate Diaz has been continuously out-sized throughout his career. Currently on a two fight losing streak, I hope Nate can find his former glory, let’s just hope he doesn’t try to move up to 170lbs again to achieve it.

Diego Sanchez – 1-0 MW, 20-4 WW, 3-3 LW, 1-0 Catchweight

From the highs of a 17-0 record to having not finished an opponent since 2008, Diego Sanchez has been on both ends of the UFC spectrum. While he is still one of the most beloved fighters in MMA, one of the biggest problems of his career has been fighting guys who are just too big for him.

After winning TUF 1 at middleweight, Sanchez moved immediately down to welterweight for his UFC debut. After starting his UFC career 6-0, Sanchez met his first two losses back to back against two of the biggest and best wrestlers in the welterweight division in Jon Fitch and Josh Koscheck.

These losses showed that, while Sanchez was successful at 170lbs, he just didn’t have the strength and size to deal with the best in that division. After winning two more times at welterweight against lower tier competitors, Sanchez dropped to 155lbs.

Despite the drop in weight, Sanchez was still an average sized Lightweight. This was the best period of his career, though, fighting his way to a title shot against BJ Penn. Despite losing that fight, Diego showed that 155lbs was a much better weight for him and many of us thought he would bounce back more aggressive than ever and fight for the title again.

Instead of continuing to fight at Lightweight, Sanchez moved back up to Welterweight. Despite winning some fights against Paulo Thiago and Martin Kampmann after going back to welterweight, Sanchez was ultimately outmatched and outclassed by the top of the division such as Jake Ellenberger and John Hathaway.

Diego again moved to 155 in 2013, but missed weight in another highly disputed win over Takanori Gomi. He would go on to loss two in a row against Gilbert Melendez and Myles Jury but halt that skid with a win against Ross Pearson in a decision that is thought of as the worst of all time.

Despite some key wins at both welterweight and lightweight, Diego has never really been the right size for either class. That, combined with his less-than-technical fighting style, he has been beaten consistently when it comes to fighting the top of either division.

Recent underground rumblings suggest Sanchez is planning a move to featherweight, which could well put him on the other side of this list as a great decision for his career. At 145lbs Sanchez would be the bigger and stronger fighter more times than not, which plays right into his style. The only question is at 33 years old, and with 32 fights to his name, is it too late for The Nightmare?

BJ Penn – 2-0 MW, 3-5-1 WW, 11-3-1 LW, 0-1 FW,0-1 Catchweight

There are not many fighters in the world who can fight on the same level of BJ Penn, but to do it in as many weight divisions as he has is nearly impossible. Despite BJ Penn’s wide array of weight classes, he will always been considered the king of the 155lbs Lightweights.

BJ started his career at lightweight, destroying anyone that stepped before him. A loss to Jens Pulver followed by a draw to Caol Uno halted his enormous progress, though. It was after the draw to Uno that BJ moved up to Welterweight and shocked the world when he defeated Matt Hughes and earned the title. Despite being at Welterweight, this was one of Penn’s greatest performances, and, in retrospect, seemed to give him the confidence to fight in many other weight classes, most of which he had no business fighting in.

What followed was a Coney Island-esque sideshow period of his career, fighting the likes of Rodrigo Gracie at middleweight and a 225lbs Lyoto Machida during his short stint in K-1.

BJ returned to the UFC in 2006 at welterweight and was beaten in his first two fights by Matt Hughes and Georges St Pierre. Now, it is hard to criticise BJ’s performance in these two fights, as they were against two of the best 170lbers in the history of the sport. Nonetheless, Penn showed that welterweight was not the weight class for him as he was out grappled by the bigger and much more athletic wrestlers.

After these hard losses, BJ moved back down to his original weight at lightweight and put forward a streak of wins that would solidify him as the greatest lightweight of all time. BJ finished Jens Pulver, Sean Sherk and Joe Stevenson, picking up the lightweight title in the latter of the three. On this incredible hot streak in which he showed his full arsenal of skills, BJ took a super fight again at welterweight and again against Georges St. Pierre. In this Welterweight rematch, it was the bigger, stronger, more athletic Georges St. Pierre that eventually got the stoppage victory over Penn when Penn couldn’t continue past the 4th round.

BJ returned to defend his lightweight strap and record two more sensational stoppage wins over Kenny Florian and Diego Sanchez, bringing his overall lightweight record to 11-1-1. It was at this time that BJ was argued to be the best fighter on the planet, that is, until he came across the relatively unknown New Jersey wrestler Frankie Edgar.

Frankie would put an end to BJ’s streak, taking his title and beating him again in an immediate rematch. At 32 years old, and knowing he wasn’t going to beat Edgar, BJ moved back to 170lbs where he flash KO’d Matt Hughes in 20 seconds and drew with Jon Fitch. These two performances were decent, but they were not the BJ we had grown to love at 155lbs, and it seemed the years of abuse were finally catching up with the once great Hawaiian. In his last two fights at welterweight, he came up against the cream of the crop in Nick Diaz and Rory MacDonald and was destroyed by both men.

Contemplating retirement, BJ wanted one more shot at greatness and asked for one more shot at Frankie Edgar, only this time it was at Frankie’s current division of 145lbs. It was at this new weight class where his career would make its final turn and Penn would take his final bow. Upon reflection, BJ should have never taken the featherweight fight against Edgar. He forced himself to cut down to the lightest he had ever been at 35 years old to take on one of the top 5 featherweights in the world. Not only did he take on one of the best, but he fought a man in Edgar who had previously beaten him twice. This fight had disaster written all over it from the moment it was announced, and the contest was completely one sided for Edgar, who stopped Penn in the third round.

BJ Penn will forever go down as one of the pioneers of MMA, but the only question is, what if BJ stayed at lightweight his entire career? This is where we saw the most dominant Penn. He had some minor success at any other division he fought, but was ultimately beaten by the best. Lightweight is where BJ belonged and it’s a shame we didn’t see more of him there.

 

Honourable Mentions

Kenny Florian -0-1 MW, 4-1 WW, 9-3 LW, 1-1 FW

Michael Bisping – 14-1 LHW, 12-6 MW

Hector Lombard – 6-0 (1NC) LHW, 24-4-1 MW, 2-0 Catchweight, 2-0 1(NC) WW

Lyoto Machida – 17-4 LHW, 3-2 MW, 2-0 Catchweight

Demetrious Johnson- 14-2 BW, 8-0-1 FLW

 

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Fighter Profile

Jake Collier Re-Signs with the UFC

Published

on

UFC light heavyweight, Jake Collier (11-4, 3-3 UFC) , took to twitter yesterday, announcing a four fight contract renewal with the promotion.

The Missouri-born, Collier, amassed a 7-1 professional record fighting exclusively in his home state. Following his next fight, a 1st round submission victory over Gabriel Checco in the RFA promotion, Collier signed with the UFC.

Originally, Collier signed as a middleweight. His promotional debut took place in December of 2014 at, UFC Fight Night 58. A bout which he lost to Vitor Miranda via TKO (Head kick and punches) with only one second remaining in the opening round.

In 2017, “The Prototype”, moved to the light heavyweight division. The move came after a three-year stint at middleweight that saw him go 2-2. Losing to the likes of Dongi Yang, while defeating Ricardo Abreu. His final fight at the lower weight earned him a performance of the night bonus in his, UFC Fight Night 88, TKO win over Alberto Uda.

Upon moving to light heavyweight, Collier has the same .500 win percentage with a record of 1-1. His debut at the weight originally scheduled him against John Stansbury. Unfortunately, Collier withdrew from the card due to injury. Devin Clark replaced him on, The Ultimate Fighter Finale: 24, and defeated John Stansbury by unanimous decision. Clark then fought Collier next, defeating him by unanimous decision. “The Prototype”s most recent bout, a victory over Marcel Fortuna in November at, UFC Fight Night 120.

According to, UFC.com, Collier is booked to fight UFC-newcomer, Marcin Prachnio at, UFC on Fox 28, in Orlando, Florida. The only bout booked to the February 24th card, of next year.

Prachnio, holds a record of 13-2, with 10 knockouts. He most recently fought for the Asian-based promotion, One Championship. The Karate practitioner comes to the UFC on an eight fight win streak, the previous four in One Championship. At twenty-nine, Prachnio is another, in his prime, European light heavyweight signed to the UFC this year (Volkan Oezdemir being the other).

 

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading

Fighter Profile

FURY FC 17 Preview: UFC Veteran Roger Narvaez Set to Fight For Gold

Published

on

Deep in the Hill Country of Texas, there is a storm of MMA action brewing on the horizon in the historic city of San Antonio.

In 1836 the most iconic siege ever to take place in the American West was waged between Santa Anna’s Mexican forces and a small band of Texans fighting for their independence at the Battle of the Alamo. On June 10th that tradition of never backing down continues as Fury Fighting Championships 17 takes place at the Shrine Auditorium with a card that was originally slated to have 20 bouts of MMA action. At the top of the bill, there will be a familiar face as former UFC fighter, Roger “The Silverback” Narvaez, looks to capture his first championship in the sport when he faces Antonio “Doomsday” Jones for the vacant middleweight title. The event will also feature a hot prospect, a kickboxing champion, and a grudge match.

Fury FC 17 will be broadcast live on FloCombat.com.

While the 33-year-old Narvaez (8-2 MMA, 1-2 UFC) has already realized his ultimate goal of getting to the highest level of MMA, fighting for a title has always eluded him. The 6’3″ fighter nicknamed “The Silverback” due to his abnormal 79.5″ wingspan, or monkey arms as he calls them was twice scheduled to fight for the Legacy Fighting Championship Middleweight Title against then champion Bubba Bush who now fights in the UFC. An injury caused the first fight to be canceled. Then a call up to the UFC to fight an unknown opponent on short notice put an end to plans for the another scheduled title fight.

Theodorou vs. Narvaez at UFC 185 (photo: Matthew Wells – MMA Latest)

 

To Roger, the secret to grabbing the attention of the world’s biggest MMA promotion is fighting for several different promotions. He fought for six different organizations winning all of his fights before getting a call from the UFC’s former matchmaker Joe Silva to ask if he was ready to make the move. Narvaez feels that fighting for multiple shows tells the UFC that a fighter is ready to fight whoever and whenever. His first fight for the promotion was a loss to Patrick Cummins at UFC Fight Night 42 in Albuquerque where he fought at an altitude of over 5300 feet sea level, something he says will not do again unless he is training at altitude. To put it bluntly, he plainly states “the altitude in Albuquerque sucks.” After a win against Luke Barnett, he faced Elias Theodorou. In that fight, he broke his arm before ultimately losing, and was then cut by the UFC.


At this point in Narvaez’s career, his goals now are different:

“The next goal for me, to be realistic, is to make as much money as I can. I love fighting, but at the same time, I have a family that I am trying to support. That is always first and foremost now…[and] Fury is doing a pretty good job of taking care of me…This is a really big deal for me. I am probably training harder for this fight than I have ever trained before. Part of that is with age comes knowledge and experience and I am doing everything I need to do the right way to get ready to come home with that strap, but that strap means ever thing…I didn’t quit fighting with a broken arm, it is going to take something pretty drastic to get me stop. I don’t think the guy I am fighting is going to be able to break my will or test my heart to where I am not going to be able to pull through…coming home with that title is a big deal.”

That home is one of a fighting family. Narvaez’s wife Brandi is also a fighter who recently made her professional debut at Legacy Fighting Alliance 7. His stepson is a gray belt who competes in Jui-Jitsu year round, his daughter also trains in the sport. They understand the hard work that their dad puts in more so than the average fighter’s family. As he puts “it’s not normal, but it is normal to us.”


The prospect to keep an eye on is Two-time Alabama state wrestling champion turned lightweight MMA fighter, Alec Williams (5-1 MMA) from Birmingham. Williams will be looking to rebound from his first professional loss as he takes on Travonne “Prince Scorpion” Hobbs. In his last fight, Alec relied on his wrestling and got it in his head that he did not want to stand and trade with his opponent. That mentality ultimately not only cost him his undefeated record but also to sustain four broken bones in the right side of his face.

“I didn’t get knocked out, I still got the takedown after I broke those four bones. I know it is going to be pretty difficult to knock me out…Honestly, the loss kind of took any pressure off. Before I was undefeated, that loss was going to be a big change and now a loss is just another loss.”

For this fight, Williams says he has been working with MMA legend and former UFC fighter Pete Spratt on his stand up and will not make the same mistake twice.


Also featured on the card is the first Brazilan World Cup Kickboxing Champion, welterweight Washington “Washingthai” Luiz. Originally slated to fight Nickolay Veretennikov, “Washingthai” Luiz will now take on lesser known Danny Ageday. With a new opponent on just four days notice, the man who has aspirations to become a champion in GLORY Kickboxing is not fazed.

“I did my whole camp studying my first opponent who is a striker like me, but I do not feel harmed by the change. I’m ready for this war…The main reason for my change to the USA is the opportunity to be in the biggest events in the world I have already fought the biggest events in Brazil in kickboxing and MMA. I have fought in big events in Europe and now my challenge is the biggest event of kickboxing, GLORY. But I also love MMA and when a fight appears for me, I do not refuse.”


The grudge match at Fury FC 17 comes to us from the flyweights division’s Mark “The Sparrow” Plata and David “Gallito” Miramontes. These two men were scheduled to fight previously but Plata had to pull out due to his wife giving birth to twins. According to Plata, that is where the beef began.

“The day my twins were born he was messaging me talking about how this was not a good reason not fight and that I just did not want to fight him. My kids were in ICU at the time and he just keeps messaging me over and over…it upset me at the time because they were dying, they were trying to survive, but it just added more fuel to the fire. Then he kept asking promoters to fight me. He asked two or three different promoters to set it up. I got tired of him asking for me. So then I was like, alright cool if you want it that bad, let’s do it…His fighting style matches his personality. He tries to be a bully, and that’s cool, I don’t mind shutting bullies down.”

Titles, champions, prospects, legitimate bad blood…what more you could ask for in a local card?

This is an event not to miss and thanks to Fury FC having a deal with FloSports, you do not have to.

Tune in for all the action live at 6:00 PM CST on FloCombat.com this Saturday.

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading

Fighter Profile

*VIDEO* Francis Ngannou has his eyes on the UFC Heavyweight Title

Matthew Wells

Published

on

UFC Heavyweight Francis “The Predator” Ngannou has taken the heavyweight division by storm.

Currently 5-0 in the UFC and riding a 9 fight win streak, the native of Cameroon possesses vicious power and has shown improvements each time he steps inside the cage.

Hear Ngannou talk about his journey and plans for the future:

Onnit Primal Bells
Continue Reading

Trending